Site icon Melestrua's Musings

One D&D Playtest 2 – Part 1 Expert Classes

This is one of my posts on the evolution of D&D. See here for other related posts.

As I discussed in my earlier post, Wizards are now working on the 10th Anniversary next edition of D&D, and they are playtesting it bit by bit. Their aim is evolution rather than revolution, and to remain compatible with fifth edition, at least to the point where you can mix and match old and new publications. (At least, that’s my understanding.) On the other hand, they are now definitely saying things will change:

There will be many fundamental updates to D&D that we will collect your feedback on. In the upcoming Unearthed Arcana playtest content, you’ll see proposed updates to character backgrounds, races, classes, feats, information presentation, and more. Ultimately, the answer to what will change depends on what we hear from you throughout One D&D playtests.

The first playtest covered the first parts of character creation – races and backgrounds – plus various rules (mostly) associated with that. The second playtest moves on to the next step – the first set of classes.

As before, you can sign up to the playtest via D&D Beyond and download the new proposals. And again as before, they are marked as Unearthed Arcana, so “aren’t officially part of the game and aren’t permitted in D&D Adventurers League events, nor are they available for use on D&D Beyond.”

Rule tweaks

Looking at the second playtest packet, it’s now clear they are trying various changes to rules to see how we react, and then tweaking in subsequent playtests. They call this out at the start of the second document:

If you do combine this article with the previous one, use only the rules glossary found here. In the One D&D Unearthed Arcana series, the rules glossary of each article supersedes the glossary of any previous article.

A key example here is the d20 Test, where in the first playtest they proposed the common house rule of automatic success and automatic failure on all d20 tests:

The term d20 Test encompasses the three main d20 rolls of the game: ability checks, attack rolls, and saving throws. If something in the game affects d20 Tests, it affects all three of those rolls.

[…]

ROLLING A 1

If you roll a 1 on the d20, the d20 Test automatically fails, regardless of any modifiers to the roll.

ROLLING A 20

If you roll a 20 on the d20, the d20 Test automatically succeeds, regardless of any modifiers to the roll. A player character also gains Inspiration when rolling the 20, thanks to the remarkable success.

Rolling a 20 doesn’t bypass limitations on the test, such as range and line of sight. The 20 bypasses only bonuses and penalties to the roll.

This seems extremely dangerous to me, and I said so in my feedback. It encourages the anti-pattern of a 20 giving magical powers – see my post Skills Aren’t Magic for my thoughts on that.

In the second playtest, they have reverted this:

The term d20 Test encompasses the three main d20 rolls of the game: Ability Checks, Attack Rolls, and Saving Throws. If something in the game affects d20 Tests, it affects all three of these rolls.

Whenever a player character rolls a 1 for a d20 Test, that character gains Heroic Inspiration.

The DM determines whether a d20 Test is warranted in any given circumstance.

And

The Attack Roll is one of three types of d20 Tests. This Unearthed Arcana article uses the rules for attack rolls and critical hits found in the 2014 Player’s Handbook.

So it looks like they thought it worth testing the water with this house rule, and now they are either reverting it while they look at the feedback (trying inspiration on a 1 instead of a 20), or they took the feedback on board and have reverted it. We’ll need to see what happens with this in subsequent play tests.

Class Groups

They are splitting the main classes into four groups of three:

It looks like they will be introducing prerequisites that refer to these groups, such as only a certain group being able to attune to a particular magic item, or a particular feat being restricted in the group(s) who can use it.

They also give the hint that including at least one of each group is a good starting point for a well-rounded party.

Expert Classes

The meat of this playtest is the Expert classes, Bard, Ranger and Rogue, though for now they have only included one Subclass for each. By the end they have promised a total of 48 subclasses across the 12 classes.

They are making tweaks to all of the classes, with both new features and revised versions of old features. They are also making suggestions for default selections where there are choices, presumably to make it easier to just pick up and get started without having to understand the ramifications of all the detailed options.

I am going through this with the Player’s Handbook next to, so rather than try to replicate the details I will highlight key changes that seem significant to me.

Some key things which jump out at me from all the classes:

Bard

Many things are the same. The number of spell slots per level. The bardic inspiration die, although it’s now presented in its own column rather than having a level feature change the die which although cosmetic is definitely an ease-of-use improvement. The “Bard College feature” is now listed as a “Bard Subclass feature”, but really it’s the same thing, presumably to make the tables more consistent across classes.

Hit dice are still 1d8+CON per level. Saving Throws are still Dexterity and Charisma, and Armour Training may have changed name but is still Light Armour. Tool proficiencies are still three musical instruments. Skills are presented as “Deception, Performance, Persuasion (or any three Skills of your choice)”, which boils down to the previous “Choose any three” while giving suggestions.

So what’s different?

Ranger

The Ranger was widely reckoned to be the poor relation among the classes in 5e, and received an Unearthed Arcana tweak to try to improve matters. How well have they addressed this in this playtest?

First, the things that are (effectively) the same. Hit Dice are still 1d10+CON. Saving throws are still Strength + Dexterity. Like the Bard, they make a suggestion of Skills – Athletics, Stealth and Survival in this case – but you’re free to choose from the same set. Weapons are still Simple Weapons and Martial Weapons, and Armour Training is still light and medium armour and shields. “Ranger Archetype” is now listed as “Ranger Subclass” but is still the same. The Extra Attack at level 5 is unchanged.

So, what’s different? Well, this has definitely had more of a rewrite. First the tweaks:

Now the things which really change the flavour of a ranger:

I feel these updates change the character of the Ranger class. Gone is the expert in the wilderness, replaced by a tireless, relentless hunter.

Rogue

So what has happened to the Rogue? Tweaks like Bard, major change like the Ranger, or something in between?

Again I’ll start with the things which remain roughly the same. Hit Dice are still 1d8+CON, Armour Training is still Light Armour, and Saving Throws are still Dexterity + Intelligence. As with the other two classes, the set of Skills to choose from is still the same, though they have recommendations (Acrobatics, Investigation, Sleight of Hand and Stealth in this case). Tools are also unchanged – Thieves’ Tools. “Roguish Archetype” becomes “Rogue Subclass” for consistency but it’s the same.

The features remain the same up to level 5 – Expertise, Sneak Attack and Thieves’ Cant at level 1, Cunning Action at level 2, Rogue Subclass at level 3, Feat (the new Ability Score Improvement) at level 4, and Uncanny Dodge at level 5. Reliable Talent remains at level 11 and Slippery Mind at level 15. Second Story Work is reworded and clearer, but otherwise unchanged.

There are changes, though.

Like the Bard, this feels more tweaks than a rewrite; if anything it seems even less changed.

Feats and Rule updates

This playtest adds a lot of feats, including numerous 4th-level feats (i.e. you need to be at least 4th level to take it) and those 20th-level Epic Boons. It also adds various feats with prerequisites. There are also the rule changes to look at – both in comparison to the fifth edition ruleset and in comparison to playtest one.

But this post is already quite long, so I’ll look at those in a separate post to follow.

Exit mobile version